The Build-Up: An Extreme Case of Nerves
Christopher Maloney, a 34-year-old customer service advisor from Liverpool, arrived at the Liverpool auditions for the ninth series of The X Factor (2012) as a bundle of visible anxiety. He revealed a significant background of stage fright, admitting he had wanted to audition for five years but had repeatedly filled out and then ripped up the application forms. His dedication to performing was clear, but his fear was immense.
Upon walking onto the stage to face the judges—Gary Barlow, Louis Walsh, Tulisa Contostavlos, and guest judge Geri Halliwell—Maloney was visibly shaking. The judges and the audience immediately noticed his extreme nervousness. He was almost unable to speak, struggling to introduce himself and his song choice due to his nerves. The tension in the room was palpable, with both the crowd and the judges showing concern for him. His demeanor conveyed a deep and honest vulnerability, which instantly endeared him to the people watching.
The Performance: “The Rose”
Maloney chose to perform Bette Midler’s “The Rose.” His choice was deeply personal; he dedicated the song to his late grandfather, whose funeral featured the same track as a celebration of his life. This emotional connection fueled the performance and added immense weight to the moment.
When he finally managed to steady himself and begin to sing, the transformation was astounding. The timid man who could barely speak suddenly unleashed a powerful, classic male vocal. The contrast between his crippling nervousness before the music started and the strength and emotion in his voice during the song was the key element that shocked and captivated everyone. His rendition of the classic ballad was pitch-perfect and delivered with an undeniable, raw emotion that moved many in the audience and on the judging panel to tears. 😭
The Judges’ Reaction and Aftermath
The performance concluded to a standing ovation from the entire audience, and the judges were visibly impressed and deeply moved.
- Gary Barlow, his eventual mentor, was notably effusive, asking him, “How the hell have you kept that voice hidden until now?” He praised his voice as “incredible” and “classic.”
- Louis Walsh focused on the technical brilliance, stating his voice was “like an old-school singer… it was absolutely brilliant.”
- Tulisa spoke directly to his emotional delivery, acknowledging how much his performance touched her.
- Guest judge Geri Halliwell also praised the sheer power of his voice.
Maloney’s relief and emotion after receiving this praise were intense. He was then joined on stage by his biggest supporter, his grandmother, who had encouraged him to audition. This heartwarming moment solidified his image as a devoted family man and cemented the public’s emotional investment in his journey. All four judges voted “Yes,” sending him through to the Bootcamp stage. 👍
A Wildcard Journey to the Final
Despite his stellar initial audition, Maloney struggled through the later stages of the competition, and Gary Barlow initially did not select him for his final three acts in the “Over 28s” category at Judges’ Houses. However, in a twist, The X Factor introduced a wildcard contestant chosen by a public vote among the four judges’ rejected acts.
The public voted overwhelmingly for Christopher Maloney, and he was brought back into the competition for the Live Shows as the thirteenth contestant. This demonstrated the immense popularity and emotional connection he had forged with the viewers during his audition.
Throughout the Live Shows, Christopher Maloney became a controversial, yet immensely popular, figure, often dubbed a “cabaret” or “cruise ship” singer by some of his critics, including Louis Walsh. Regardless of the critiques, he had one of the most remarkable runs in the show’s history, advancing multiple times on the public vote. He was eliminated during the first night of the Live Final, ultimately finishing in third place behind Jahméne Douglas and the eventual winner, James Arthur. His audition remains a quintessential X Factor moment, showcasing a raw talent overcoming profound nerves to achieve his dream. ✨
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings